Harrow BNG Appeal 6004526: Private Gardens Cannot Deliver Secured Biodiversity Net Gain, Historic Grassland Is the Baseline, and the Council Pays Full Costs, What the Decision Means for Ecology Surveys and Small-Site BNG (November 2026)

A 30.04 per cent biodiversity gain on paper could not be secured in Harrow, yet the appellant still won and the council was ordered to pay its full costs. Appeal 6004526, decided on 30 September 2026, shows how biodiversity net gain private gardens small sites metric questions are now decided at appeal: the baseline is what the land used to be, garden gains cannot be legally secured, and the statutory condition is judged on whether it can realistically be discharged [1]. This article is general information, not legal advice.

Key Takeaways

  • Inspector N Teasdale allowed outline permission for two detached single-storey dwellings at Eastcote Lane, Harrow, on 30 September 2026, and separately awarded the appellant its full costs against the London Borough of Harrow for unreasonable behaviour [1][2][3].
  • The pre-development baseline was historic grassland shown on 2020 aerial imagery, not the gravel seen at the site visit [1][2].
  • The Small Sites Metric showed a 30.04 per cent gain, but most of it sat in future private gardens, which the June 2026 Defra metric user guide says cannot be legally secured [1][2].
  • The appeal still succeeded because the statutory biodiversity gain condition was 'capable of being successfully discharged' through off-site units or statutory credits [1][2].

The appeal in brief: two bungalows at Eastcote Lane, Harrow

The appellant, Marlpark 71 HA4 Ltd, sought outline permission for two detached single-storey houses with rooms in the roof on land at Eastcote Lane. Harrow refused on overlooking and biodiversity net gain (BNG). The Inspector allowed the appeal with a condition that the relevant dormers be obscure glazed and non-opening [1][2]. Planning Geek reported the decision on 1 October 2026 and hosts the decision and costs letters [1][2][3].

Baseline evidence: why 2020 aerial imagery beat the gravel seen at the site visit

By the time of the Inspector's visit the site was covered in gravel, which would have produced a very low baseline and an easy uplift. Harrow relied on 2020 aerial imagery showing grassland, and the Inspector agreed that the pre-development baseline should be historic grassland [1][2]. Two points stand out for anyone preparing a biodiversity net gain private gardens small sites metric assessment:

  1. The appellant had modelled both scenarios. Its Planning Statement set out gravel and grassland baselines and accepted grassland as the proper starting point. That candour mattered when costs were considered [1][3].
  2. Historic imagery is evidence. Clearing a site shortly before a survey does not reset the baseline.

Ecologists should check historic aerial photography and local records before signing off a UKHab baseline. The site visit records what is there today; the metric asks what was there before.

A 30 per cent gain on paper that could not be secured: the private garden problem

The latest Small Sites Metric showed a net increase of 0.0421 habitat units, a 30.04 per cent gain against the statutory 10 per cent minimum [1][2]. The difficulty was where the gain sat. Much of it depended on enhanced grassland and new trees within the future private gardens, with scrub around the site edges. The June 2026 Defra Statutory Biodiversity Metric User Guide says post-development private gardens have no public access and that gains within them cannot be legally secured. Applying that guidance, the Inspector found that the long-term management and maintenance of the garden gains could not be guaranteed [1][2].

The appellant tried to redraw the garden depths so that the main habitat areas sat outside what it called the private garden curtilage. The Inspector was not persuaded: the land would still be within the residential property boundary, so the on-site arrangement did not itself secure the mandatory 10 per cent gain [1][2].

A landscape plan cannot turn garden land into secured BNG habitat by moving a garden line.

On a two-house plot almost every square metre not covered by building or driveway becomes garden. If the uplift depends on those gardens, it is not deliverable as a legally secured on-site gain.

Why the statutory biodiversity gain condition still allowed the appeal to succeed

The failure of the garden-based solution did not mean refusal. Statutory BNG under Schedule 7A to the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 operates through a deemed pre-commencement condition: a Biodiversity Gain Plan must be approved before development begins [4]. Planning Practice Guidance treats BNG as a post-permission framework and says it would generally be inappropriate to refuse an application simply because the gain objective has not yet been demonstrated [1].

The decisive question was therefore whether the statutory condition was capable of being discharged. The Inspector found sufficient certainty. A section 106 agreement or other legal mechanism might, where appropriate, secure on-site provision; more importantly, the gain hierarchy allows registered off-site habitat units or, as a last resort, statutory biodiversity credits. Both main parties regarded those routes as realistic and achievable, so the Inspector concluded the condition was 'capable of being successfully discharged' [1][2].

Harrow's own Biodiversity Gain Plan condition was omitted as duplicating the statutory condition [1][2]. The plan comes later, but the realistic route to 10 per cent must be visible at appeal. Our earlier update on the BNG 0.2 hectare exemption in force from 31 July 2026 explains which small sites now fall outside the regime altogether.

The costs award: what the Inspector said about the council's conduct

In a separate decision the Inspector awarded the appellant its full costs against the council, the amount to be agreed or assessed [1][3]. Two strands of unreasonable behaviour were identified:

  • Overlooking. The appellant had offered obscure glazed, fixed-shut dormers. Harrow accepted this dealt with actual overlooking but still relied on 'perceived' overlooking without explaining why that remained unacceptable [1][3].
  • BNG. The council had not properly engaged with the grassland scenario already set out in the Planning Statement and had not requested the specific metric documents. The Inspector said that 'Co-operation and a more helpful approach' could have avoided the appeal or narrowed its issues [1][3].

BNG objections are legitimate, but they must engage with the evidence submitted; refusing where a realistic discharge route exists carries a costs risk.

Ecology survey lessons: baselines, UKHab condition assessment and the Small Sites Metric

For consultants preparing biodiversity net gain private gardens small sites metric reports, the Harrow decision suggests a short discipline:

Stage What the decision shows Practical step
Baseline habitat Historic grassland beat present-day gravel [1][2] Check aerial imagery and records before the site visit; record any recent clearance
Habitat condition A low-distinctiveness baseline is still a baseline Complete the UKHab condition assessment on what the land was, not what it has become
Post-development habitats Garden gains cannot be secured [1][2] Score gardens honestly; do not rely on them for the 10 per cent
Delivery route Off-site units or credits were accepted as realistic [1][2] Identify a registered off-site provider or credit cost early
Documents The council had not requested the metric files [1][3] Submit the full metric workbook and user-guide version with the application

Our September 2026 note on small-site exemption and NSIP deadlines covers the exemption thresholds that decide whether a metric is needed at all.

Ecologists as expert witnesses at BNG appeals: evidence that holds up

The same evidential standards apply when an ecologist gives evidence at an inquiry, a hearing or in court. The decision shows three things a decision-maker will test [1][2]:

  1. Provenance of the baseline. Dated imagery, survey dates and the metric version used carry more weight than a single site visit.
  2. Consistency with national guidance. The Inspector applied the June 2026 Defra user guide directly; a report that ignores it invites criticism.
  3. Candour about weaknesses. The two-scenario Planning Statement showed the baseline problem had been confronted. Experts owe their duty to the decision-maker, and a report that models the unfavourable scenario is more persuasive, not less.

What small-site applicants and councils should do now

Applicants: commission the UKHab baseline before any clearance and keep dated photographs; model the realistic baseline; assume garden land will not count as secured gain and price off-site units or credits from the start; submit the complete metric workbook.

Councils: request the metric documents before refusing on BNG grounds; where a realistic discharge route exists, consider whether the statutory condition rather than refusal is proportionate; record the reasoning on actual and perceived impacts.

For the policy backdrop, see our analysis of the Biodiversity Net Gain changes of 6 August 2026 and the small site exemption.

How Biodiversity Surveyors can help

Biodiversity Surveyors provides UKHab habitat surveys, protected species surveys, BNG assessments and statutory metric calculations across England, together with independent ecological expert evidence for appeals and disputes.

FAQ

Can private gardens count towards biodiversity net gain on a small site?

Gardens can be entered in the metric, but the June 2026 Defra user guide says gains within post-development private gardens cannot be legally secured, and the Harrow Inspector applied that guidance. Do not rely on them to reach the 10 per cent minimum [1][2].

What baseline applies if a site has recently been cleared or gravelled?

The Harrow decision used historic grassland shown on 2020 aerial imagery rather than the gravel present at the site visit [1][2]. Expect the earlier habitat to be used where land has been cleared or degraded.

Does a shortfall in on-site gain mean refusal?

Not in itself. The Inspector found the statutory biodiversity gain condition was capable of being discharged through off-site units or statutory credits, and allowed the appeal [1][2].

Why did Harrow have to pay the appellant's costs?

The Inspector found the council acted unreasonably on both the overlooking and the BNG reasons, including failing to engage with the grassland scenario in the Planning Statement or to request the metric documents [1][3].

Conclusion

Appeal 6004526 does not weaken BNG; it sharpens it. Baselines must reflect what the land was, garden gains must be scored honestly, and the delivery route must be evidenced. For small-site applicants, that means an early, well-documented ecology survey, a metric that does not lean on private gardens, and a clear plan for off-site units or credits. For councils, the costs decision is a reminder to engage with the evidence before refusing.

References

  1. Planning Geek, Harrow BNG appeal ends with council ordered to pay full costs (1 October 2026). planninggeek.co.uk.
  2. Planning Inspectorate, Appeal decision 6004526, land at Eastcote Lane, Harrow (30 September 2026), PDF hosted by Planning Geek. planninggeek.co.uk.
  3. Planning Inspectorate, Costs decision 6004526 (PDF hosted by Planning Geek). planninggeek.co.uk.
  4. GOV.UK, Biodiversity net gain: guidance collection. gov.uk.
Content Overview
Table of Contents
Search
Categories ----