Hinckley BNG Appeal Dismissed Over an ‘Illegible’ Biodiversity Metric and a Missing Bat Survey: What the 11 November 2026 Decision Means for Ecological Survey Evidence (November 2026)

Two semi-detached homes on previously developed land, in a borough without a five-year housing land supply, should have been a strong appeal. It was dismissed anyway. On 11 November 2026, Inspector K Craddock refused appeal 6011672 at Moorbeck, Butt Lane Close, Hinckley, because the statutory biodiversity metric was unreadable and no current ecological survey had been carried out for bats [1]. Biodiversity Net Gain (BNG) and protected species evidence are now minimum application-stage information, not paperwork to be tidied up later.

Key Takeaways

  • The Hinckley appeal was dismissed because the metric was "poorly formatted and the information within it is unclear and illegible", so the 10% net gain could not be assessed [1].
  • A likely bat roosting risk with no up-to-date preliminary ecological appraisal meant the Inspector refused to secure surveys by condition [1].
  • The Watchfield decision (4 September 2026) confirms that months without seeing bats is no substitute for qualified survey evidence [2].
  • A robust submission needs a UKHab baseline survey by a suitably qualified ecologist, a legible metric export and matching habitat plans, and ecologists giving evidence at appeal or in court carry professional and expert witness duties [3][4].

What Went Wrong at Hinckley

The scheme (LPA ref 25/01058/FUL, Hinckley and Bosworth Borough Council) proposed two semi-detached homes plus alterations and an extension to the existing house. Two evidence failures sank it [1].

The biodiversity metric

A metric was submitted, but the Inspector described it as "poorly formatted and the information within it is unclear and illegible". Because the pre-development habitat baseline could not be read, there was no way to be satisfied it had been calculated robustly, and so no way to assess the required 10% uplift [1].

The appellant argued that detail could follow in a later biodiversity gain plan. The Inspector disagreed: a readable metric is minimum information at application stage, and the gain plan is not the place to establish the baseline for the first time [1].

The missing bat survey

The existing house roof and nearby trees created a reasonable likelihood of bat roosting or disturbance. No up-to-date preliminary ecological appraisal (PEA) or other proportionate survey was supplied. The appellant cited a lack of legal access to the land and building, and earlier roost assessments for other schemes. Neither removed the need for current evidence [1].

The land was accepted as previously developed and the council could not show a five-year supply, so the homes carried substantial weight. That weight was substantially outweighed by the adverse effects, including conflict with local plan policies N2 and DM1(2) alongside S3 and S4 [1].

Why "Secure It by Condition" Fails for Protected Species

Applicants often ask for ecological survey work to be dealt with by condition. At Hinckley, the survey condition was rejected because the risk to protected species had not been established before determination. The decision maker must understand the risk first [1].

Watchfield reinforces the point. Appeal 6008736, The Parsonage House, 90 High Street, Watchfield, Vale of White Horse, was dismissed by Inspector Alexander O'Doherty on 4 September 2026. Around 11 months of occupation and building work without seeing a protected species did not answer whether protected species were reasonably likely to be present and affected, and personal observations and photographs were no substitute for qualified bat and badger survey evidence [2].

The only qualified ecological opinion before the Inspector came from the council's Senior Ecology Officer, who identified potential bat features including lifted or broken roof slates, gaps in masonry and deteriorated timber. A construction method statement condition was also rejected as a substitute for surveys, citing Circular 06/2005 paragraph 99: surveys should normally be done before permission is granted [2].

A condition can control how work is done, but it cannot tell the decision maker whether protected species are at risk in the first place.

What a Robust Metric and Ecological Survey Submission Looks Like

Mandatory 10% BNG applies to most planning applications in England under Schedule 7A of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, inserted by the Environment Act 2021, and a completed statutory metric forms part of the minimum information for an application [5]. Defra's post-legislative scrutiny memorandum of 3 November 2026 called BNG "broadly successful for larger developments" while noting shortfalls in resources, ecological expertise and guidance, and mandatory BNG now extends to nationally significant infrastructure projects from 2 November 2026 [5].

A submission that will stand up to scrutiny usually contains the following.

Component What good looks like
UKHab baseline survey Carried out by a suitably qualified ecologist at a time of year when habitats can be identified with confidence
Condition assessment Each habitat parcel scored against the published criteria, with reasoning recorded
Metric export A legible export with every baseline and post-development sheet readable and totals visible
Habitat plans Clear pre- and post-development plans whose parcels match the metric line by line
Stated assumptions Assumptions about retained habitat, timing, management or off-site units set out in writing

A metric that cannot be read is treated as no metric at all. The export should be checked before submission, ideally by someone who did not prepare it. Biodiversity Surveyors prepares BNG assessments on this basis, pairing the field survey with a reviewed metric export and matching plans so the decision maker can follow the calculation from start to finish.

PEAs, Survey Seasons and the Cost of a Missed Window

A PEA is the first-stage ecological survey of a site. It records habitats, identifies features that could support protected species and recommends further surveys, showing the decision maker that ecological risk was considered before determination.

Bat roost assessments and emergence surveys are seasonal, and badger activity is also assessed against seasonal patterns. An application submitted without the right surveys may be held until the next window opens, adding months to the programme. Submitting without them and hoping for a condition failed at both Hinckley and Watchfield [1][2].

Practical scheduling points:

  • Commission the PEA early, before the design is fixed.
  • Treat every existing roof and mature tree near the works as a potential bat feature until a qualified ecologist has assessed it.
  • Secure lawful access to the whole site, including buildings; lack of access was not accepted at Hinckley [1].
  • Do not rely on reports prepared for other schemes; current evidence is needed [1].

Biodiversity Surveyors offers PEAs and protected species surveys across England and can advise on the survey calendar so an application is not delayed by a missed window.

Ecologists as Expert Witnesses

Once a refusal is appealed, ecological evidence becomes witness evidence.

Professional witnesses at planning appeals

At written representations, hearings and inquiries, ecologists give evidence as professional witnesses under Planning Inspectorate procedures and the CIEEM Code of Professional Conduct [3]. Watchfield shows how much weight a single qualified opinion carries when it is the only one before the Inspector [2].

Expert witnesses in court

In court proceedings, ecologists act as expert witnesses under Part 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules, with an overriding duty to the court rather than to the party paying them [4]. Independence is central.

AI declarations

The Civil Justice Council's final report of October 2026 recommends that experts declare where AI has generated or influenced the substantive content of a report. This is a recommendation, not yet a rule [3], but ecologists using AI tools should keep a record of that use now.

Practical Checklist for Applicants

  1. Confirm whether mandatory BNG applies and record the reasoning for any exemption claimed.
  2. Instruct a suitably qualified ecologist to carry out a UKHab baseline survey and condition assessment at the right time of year.
  3. Obtain a PEA and complete any protected species surveys it recommends before determination.
  4. Export the statutory metric and check that every sheet is legible and that totals, parcels and plans agree.
  5. State assumptions clearly, including retained habitats, management and any off-site units.
  6. Record who prepared each document, their qualifications and any AI tools used.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the biodiversity metric be submitted after permission is granted?

No. The Hinckley Inspector treated a completed, legible statutory metric as minimum information at application stage. The later biodiversity gain plan is for delivery, not for establishing the baseline [1].

If no bats have been seen on site, is a bat survey still needed?

Usually yes, where features with roost potential exist. At Watchfield, around 11 months of occupation without a sighting did not answer whether protected species were reasonably likely to be present and affected [2].

Why was a survey condition refused at Hinckley?

Because the risk to protected species had not been established before determination. A condition cannot substitute for the evidence needed to understand that risk [1].

Do ecologists need to declare the use of AI in expert reports?

Not yet as a rule. The Civil Justice Council's October 2026 final report recommends such declarations where AI has generated or influenced the substantive content of a report [3].

Conclusion

Hinckley and Watchfield both failed on evidence. An illegible metric meant the 10% uplift could not be assessed; the absence of a current ecological survey meant protected species risk could not be understood. Neither gap could be closed by a condition.

Next steps: commission a PEA early, book protected species surveys within the correct season, insist on a legible metric export with matching habitat plans, and record who prepared the evidence and how. Where a decision may be contested, choose ecologists who understand their duties as professional or expert witnesses. Good evidence at application stage costs far less than a dismissed appeal.

References

  1. Planning Geek, "Hinckley BNG appeal fails over illegible metric", 11 November 2026. planninggeek.co.uk.
  2. Planning Geek, "Protected species survey needed despite no bats being seen", 6 September 2026. planninggeek.co.uk.
  3. Lewis Silkin, "CJC final report on AI and court documents", 5 November 2026. lewissilkin.com.
  4. Ministry of Justice, Civil Procedure Rules Part 35. justice.gov.uk.
  5. Planning Geek, "Environment Act review flags biodiversity delivery gaps", 3 November 2026. planninggeek.co.uk.