The appellant's own ecological appraisal said the ponds needed testing. The council's ecologist said the same. The great crested newt eDNA survey was still never done, and on 12 November 2026 a Planning Inspector dismissed an appeal for up to five homes in rural Essex, refusing to let the missing survey be dealt with by condition. The decision in appeal 6009888 at Little Easton, reported by Planning Geek on 13 November 2026, is a clear warning to developers and ecologists about what happens when survey evidence arrives late, incomplete or not at all [1].
Key Takeaways
- Montare LLP's appeal against Uttlesford District Council's refusal of outline permission for up to five dwellings north of Duck Street, Little Easton, was dismissed on 12 November 2026.
- Great crested newt eDNA surveys of ponds and wet ditches within 500 metres were missing, despite the appellant's own appraisal and earlier council advice flagging the need.
- New survey material submitted with the appeal was given no reliance because it lacked adequate mapping and methodology and the council's ecologist had not had a proper chance to consider it.
- The Inspector refused to defer the surveys to a planning condition.
- A partial costs award was made against the council, but only on the drainage reason for refusal, not on ecology.
The appeal in outline
Montare LLP applied to Uttlesford District Council under reference UTT/25/2736/OP for outline permission for up to five dwellings on an open grassed field north of Duck Street, between Little Easton and Mill End in Essex. The council refused on several grounds, including location, rural character, drainage and ecology [1].
On appeal, the Inspector treated the site as countryside rather than part of the village. The appeal was dismissed because the harm from the site's location and its effect on the landscape outweighed the benefits, and because the great crested newt evidence was inadequate [1].
Why the great crested newt eDNA survey decided the ecology issue
| Issue | What the Inspector found |
|---|---|
| Survey scope | eDNA surveys of ponds and wet ditches within 500 metres of the site were required and had not been carried out |
| Prior warnings | The appellant's own ecological appraisal and earlier council advice had both identified the need |
| Late material | New survey information submitted with the appeal lacked adequate mapping and methodology; the council's ecologist had not had a proper opportunity to review it |
| Conditions | The Inspector refused to leave the surveys to a condition |
The result is that an outline scheme for five homes failed on ecology grounds that were foreseeable from the appellant's own documents [1].
The appellant's appraisal identified the survey gap. The council's ecologist identified it again. The appeal was lost on it.
The costs decision
The appellant sought a full award of costs against the council. The Inspector refused that but made a partial award limited to the expense of contesting the second reason for refusal, which concerned drainage. The Inspector found that reason inadequately supported, describing the council's reasoning as "vaguely expressed and lacking in objective analysis", and accepted that the drainage information was adequate for an outline application with a detailed scheme capable of being secured by condition. The amount is to be agreed between the parties or formally assessed [1].
No costs were awarded in relation to the ecology reason. The council was entitled to insist on the great crested newt eDNA survey, and it was the appellant's failure to provide it that decided the issue [1].
A related point on biodiversity net gain
Planning Geek's report of the Little Easton decision does not mention biodiversity net gain. Separately, Freeths' Environmental Law Update published on 1 November 2026, covering October 2026, records that in appeal 6008794 the Planning Inspectorate held that the statutory 10% biodiversity net gain regime does not apply to section 73A retrospective permissions, so a BNG condition was unnecessary in that case [2]. Developers should not read that narrow point across to ordinary applications, where mandatory BNG continues to apply.
Great crested newt eDNA survey practice: what should have happened
As a matter of general industry practice, eDNA sampling of ponds for great crested newts is undertaken within a defined spring to early summer window, typically from mid-April to the end of June, when newts are present in the water and DNA is detectable. Outside that window, a negative result is not reliable and a positive result still requires follow-up population surveys. None of this comes from the appeal decision itself; it is the practical context that explains why missing a season can derail a planning timetable by a year.
A compliant approach for a site like Little Easton would normally involve:
- a desk study and preliminary ecological appraisal identifying all ponds and wet ditches within 500 metres;
- a Habitat Suitability Index assessment of each water body;
- eDNA sampling by a licensed surveyor within the survey window, with laboratory analysis;
- where positives are returned, population class surveys and a mitigation or licensing strategy;
- clear mapping showing each sampled water body, access constraints and any ponds that could not be surveyed, with reasons.
Ecologists as expert witnesses at appeal
The Inspector's treatment of the late survey material is the sharpest lesson for ecologists appearing in appeals, hearings and inquiries. Evidence that lacks mapping and methodology, and that the other side's specialist has not been able to examine, will not be relied upon.
Ecologists giving evidence should work to the same disciplines as surveyor expert witnesses under CPR Part 35 and Practice Direction 35: state the instructions, set out the survey methods, dates, personnel and licences, present the data in a form the decision-maker and the opposing expert can check, give reasons and acknowledge limitations. The CIEEM Code of Professional Conduct requires members to be objective and to present findings honestly and completely. An ecologist who submits a partial survey late in the process risks both the client's appeal and their own professional standing.
What this means for developers and landowners
- Commission the full suite of protected species surveys before submission, not after refusal. The survey calendar, not the planning timetable, controls when eDNA sampling can be done.
- Treat your own ecologist's recommendations as binding. If the appraisal says survey the ponds, survey the ponds.
- Do not expect an Inspector to accept surveys by condition where the information was foreseeably needed to determine the application.
- Engage the council ecologist early and give them time to review any new data before the appeal.
What this means for ecology surveyors and planning consultants
- Build the eDNA window into every project programme and warn clients in writing when it will be missed.
- Present all survey data with maps, methods, dates and limitations so that it can be scrutinised and relied upon.
- Where new evidence is produced for an appeal, share it with the authority's ecologist in good time and record that you have done so.
- Separate factual survey results from professional opinion in every report, in line with expert witness practice.
Conclusion
The Little Easton decision is not a complicated one, and that is the point. A great crested newt eDNA survey that both sides knew was needed was never carried out, late material could not fill the gap, and the Inspector refused to let a condition do the work. The partial costs award on drainage does nothing to change the outcome on ecology. For developers and ecologists alike, the lesson is to survey in season, document thoroughly and share early. The decision is reported by Planning Geek, which links to the Planning Inspectorate's full appeal and costs decisions [1].
References
- Planning Geek, Partial costs award despite failed Little Easton appeal, 13 November 2026. planninggeek.co.uk.
- Freeths, Environmental Law Update November 2026, 1 November 2026. freeths.co.uk.
