Lostock Gralam Appeal 6010018 Dismissed on 17 November 2026: A 12% Biodiversity Uplift Accepted but No Delivery Timetable, What It Means for Biodiversity Metrics, Baselines and Ecology Evidence (November 2026)

The planting was acceptable. The lowered bunds were acceptable. The biodiversity metric showed a 12% uplift and the inspector was satisfied with it. The appeal was still dismissed. On 17 November 2026 a planning inspector refused to approve a landscape and biodiversity enhancement scheme for a storage site at Lostock Gralam, near Northwich in Cheshire, because it did not say when any of it would be delivered, according to a report of the decision published the same day [1]. For anyone preparing a biodiversity net gain metric or ecology survey for an appeal, the case carries two lessons: baselines are still contested, and a scheme with no timetable is not a scheme.

Key Takeaways

  • Appeal dismissed. Inspector R Major refused to approve the details submitted under a landscape and biodiversity condition (appeal reference 6010018).
  • The fatal gap was the timetable. The condition required an implementation timetable. The submission gave maintenance details but no dates or stages. The inspector called the timetable "a fundamental requirement of the condition".
  • The metric passed. An uplift from 16.89 to 18.92 habitat units, about 12%, measured against the site's existing condition, was found satisfactory.
  • The baseline was disputed. The council's ecology officer argued the metric should have been measured against the pre-development condition.
  • Statutory BNG did not apply. The permission had been granted on an earlier enforcement appeal, so the biodiversity requirement came from a bespoke condition.

Background to the appeal

The site is on Moss Lane, Lostock Gralam, a former industrial site now used for the storage and distribution of refrigerated trailers. That use was granted planning permission on an earlier enforcement appeal. The permission came with a condition requiring a landscape and biodiversity enhancement scheme to be submitted and approved. The condition also had teeth: if its requirements were not met, the use would have to stop and the trailers be removed.

The operator submitted a scheme to Cheshire West and Chester Council. The council did not decide it in time, and the operator appealed.

The scheme proposed to:

  • reduce the existing earth bunds from between 2 and 2.5 metres to about 1.25 metres;
  • form low internal mounds;
  • keep existing trees, scrub and grassland;
  • add native shrubs and trees; and
  • install dark green mesh fencing.

What the inspector accepted

On the substance, the operator did well. The planting species, the look of the lowered bunds and the maintenance arrangements were all found acceptable.

On biodiversity, the figures were:

Measure Habitat units
Existing habitat score 16.89
Projected score with the scheme 18.92
Uplift about 12%

The council's ecology officer raised two concerns. The first was that the metric should be run against the site as it was before the development took place, not as it is now. The second was about a priority deciduous woodland habitat and other woodland on the site. The inspector noted that little information had been supplied about how the scheme would affect those habitats.

Even so, the inspector found the 12% increase satisfactory. The reasoning turned on the wording of the condition. It asked for biodiversity enhancement commensurate with the development, backed by metric evidence and a habitat assessment. It did not fix a pre-development baseline or a set percentage.

Why statutory biodiversity net gain did not apply

In an ordinary case in England, a new planning permission carries the statutory biodiversity gain condition. A Biodiversity Gain Plan showing at least a 10% gain must be approved before work starts.

This site was different. The earlier enforcement appeal had established that the statutory regime does not apply to a permission granted when an enforcement notice appeal succeeds on the ground that permission ought to be given. So the only biodiversity requirement was the bespoke condition written by the earlier inspector.

The report also records that the inspector referred to national policy, which now tells decision-makers not to give weight to local plan policies that demand biodiversity gains beyond the statutory framework, including for exempt development [1].

A bespoke condition is read on its own words. If it does not name a baseline date or a percentage, neither will be read in.

Why the appeal failed anyway

The condition required a timetable for carrying the scheme out. The submission explained how planting would be maintained once in place. It did not say when the bunds would be lowered, when planting would happen or in what stages.

Without that, the council could not be sure the measures would ever be delivered, and nor could the inspector. The scheme could not be approved.

The decision did not reopen the principle of the storage use, and it did not decide whether the cessation mechanism in the condition has been triggered. But the operator now holds a permission with a key condition still not discharged.

Lessons for biodiversity net gain metric and ecology survey evidence at appeal

1. Read the condition word by word. Every element it asks for must be in the submission: the plan, the metric, the habitat assessment, the management and the timetable. A strong ecology report cannot make up for a missing item.

2. State the baseline and defend it. Say plainly what date and what site condition the baseline habitat survey reflects, and why that is the right one. Under the statutory regime, there are rules that can take the baseline back to an earlier date where habitats have been degraded. Under a bespoke condition, the wording governs.

3. Deal with priority habitats head on. Where woodland or other priority habitat is present, the report should map it, give its condition and explain the effect of the scheme. The inspector noted the lack of information here even though the appeal failed on other grounds.

4. Give dates, not just durations. A 30-year management plan is of little use if nobody knows when year one starts. Tie works to planting seasons and to fixed points after approval.

5. Make the metric legible and traceable. Each habitat parcel in the metric should match a parcel on the plan and a line in the survey. Decision-makers need to follow the numbers without guessing.

6. Remember the expert's duty. An ecologist whose report goes before an inspector or a court is giving expert opinion. It should be independent, reasoned and clear about its limits.

What it means for developers and landowners

  • Retrospective schemes carry extra risk. Where development has already happened, expect argument about what the site was like before, and collect aerial imagery and earlier survey data.
  • Conditions with cessation clauses are high stakes. A refused discharge can put the whole use in doubt. Submissions should be checked against the condition by someone other than the author.
  • Delay costs money. A fresh submission with a proper timetable is likely to be needed. That is a second round of fees that a single page of dates would have avoided.

Frequently Asked Questions

Was this a statutory biodiversity net gain case?
No. The statutory condition did not apply because the permission was granted on an enforcement appeal. A bespoke condition applied.

Did the inspector reject the biodiversity metric?
No. The roughly 12% uplift against the existing site was found satisfactory under this condition.

Why was the appeal dismissed?
Because the submission had no implementation timetable, which the condition required.

Does a 12% uplift against the existing site satisfy statutory BNG elsewhere?
Not necessarily. Statutory cases have their own baseline rules and require an approved Biodiversity Gain Plan.

Conclusion

The Lostock Gralam decision shows that sound ecology can be undone by an incomplete submission. It also shows that the choice of baseline remains the first thing a council ecologist will test.

Developers should have their biodiversity submissions checked line by line against the condition before they go in. Ecologists should set out the baseline, the metric and the delivery programme so that each can be followed and verified. Where a dispute is likely, independent ecological advice at the start is cheaper than a second appeal.

This article is general information on a recent appeal decision and is not legal or planning advice.

References

  1. Planning Geek, Biodiversity condition appeal fails over timetable (17 November 2026). planninggeek.co.uk.
Content Overview
Table of Contents
Search
Categories ----
Recent Post ----