An eight-home scheme in Surrey cleared the Green Belt hurdle, had no fatal problem with Biodiversity Net Gain, and was proposed in a district with a housing shortfall. It was still refused. On 12 November 2026 a planning inspector dismissed appeal 6010654 at Rook Lane, Chaldon, because of two ecology gaps: nobody had surveyed for bats, and four of the houses would stand within 15 metres of ancient woodland [1]. As a bat survey planning appeal, it is a clear example of how missing ecological evidence can outweigh everything a scheme has in its favour.
Key Takeaways
- A Preliminary Ecological Appraisal identified habitat suitable for bats, but no bat surveys followed.
- The inspector held that the gap could not be filled by a planning condition.
- The appraisal did not refer to Natural England's standing advice on ancient woodland, which calls for a buffer of at least 15 metres.
- With rear gardens running up to the woodland edge, the inspector found there would be no buffer zone at all.
- Biodiversity Net Gain was not the problem. Protected species and irreplaceable habitat were.
The appeal at a glance
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Appeal reference | 6010654 |
| Site | 75 and land rear of 77 Rook Lane, Chaldon, Surrey |
| Local planning authority | Tandridge District Council |
| Proposal | 8 detached four-bedroom dwellings with parking and landscaping |
| Inspector | Jane Smith |
| Site visit | 13 October 2026 |
| Decision | Dismissed, 12 November 2026 |
The site is a grazing paddock with a metal-clad animal shelter. It backs on to woodland known as Willey Broom [1].
The inspector identified a long list of main issues, including Green Belt policy, the character of the area, the setting of nearby listed buildings, drainage and housing mix. Two of them concerned ecology: the effect on ancient woodland, and the effect on bats, which are European Protected Species.
The ancient woodland buffer
Ancient woodland is classed in national policy as irreplaceable habitat. Natural England and the Forestry Commission publish standing advice for planning decisions affecting it. That advice recommends a buffer zone of at least 15 metres of semi-natural habitat between development and the woodland, to avoid root damage and wider harm [2]. Gardens are not treated as part of a buffer.
The council's ecological consultee relied on that advice. The appellant's Preliminary Ecological Appraisal, dated July 2025, had noted the woodland and recommended good practice during construction. But, as the inspector recorded, it:
"did not, however, refer to the NE standing advice" [1]
On the submitted layout, four of the eight dwellings would be within 15 metres of the site boundary, and their rear gardens would run up to the woodland edge. The inspector concluded that there would be no buffer zone.
A boundary fence was not an answer. Fencing does not stop domestic cats, and it does not stop dust, light, or pollution of water, air and soil. The inspector found the scheme would be extremely likely to trigger deterioration of the irreplaceable habitat. No compensation strategy had been offered, and there were no wholly exceptional reasons to justify the harm [1].
The missing bat surveys in this planning appeal
The Preliminary Ecological Appraisal recognised that the site had some suitability for foraging and commuting bats. That is what a preliminary appraisal is for: to flag what needs further survey. The further surveys were never done.
Three specific gaps emerged.
- The building. The animal shelter would be demolished or moved to make way for the access drive. The council's ecologist asked for more evidence about its potential as a roost. Without survey evidence, the inspector held that its use as a roost could not safely be ruled out.
- The trees. The appraisal assumed that no trees would be felled. The arboricultural evidence showed that two small trees would be removed. They had not been assessed for bats.
- The lighting. The appraisal stated there would be no new artificial lighting. But several new windows would face the woodland edge, and light spill from homes can disturb bats using a woodland margin.
The inspector's conclusion was that there was credible evidence bats could be present, and no survey evidence to show otherwise [1].
Could the surveys be required by condition after permission? No. Applying Circular 06/2005, the inspector held that the gap could not be rectified by imposing planning conditions. The presence of a protected species, and the extent to which it would be affected, has to be established before permission is granted. A decision-maker cannot weigh an impact that has not been measured.
Biodiversity Net Gain was not the problem
It would be easy to assume that an ecology refusal in 2026 is about the statutory 10 per cent net gain. Here it was not.
The inspector noted that the biodiversity metric would need updating, because private gardens cannot be counted towards the gain, and that off-site units would be needed. But baseline information had been supplied. The inspector saw no clear reason why the biodiversity gain condition could not be discharged in due course [1].
This is an important distinction. Biodiversity Net Gain is normally dealt with after permission, through the biodiversity gain plan. Protected species and irreplaceable habitats are different. They must be resolved before the decision, and off-site units cannot buy a way round them.
The planning balance
The scheme had real points in its favour. The inspector accepted that the development was not inappropriate in the Green Belt, and gave weight to the delivery of housing where supply is short.
It did not help. Where national policies protecting habitats and protected species give a clear reason for refusal, the usual presumption in favour of sustainable development does not operate in the same way. The inspector found that those policies indicated the development should be refused, and that the adverse effects substantially outweighed the benefits [1].
What this means for ecology surveys
A preliminary appraisal is the start, not the finish. If the appraisal identifies potential for bats, the recommended follow-up, such as a preliminary roost assessment of buildings and trees and, where needed, emergence or activity surveys in season, must be carried out and reported before the application is decided.
Check the appraisal against the other drawings. In this appeal the ecology report assumed no tree loss and no new lighting. The arboricultural report and the elevations said otherwise. Ecologists should see the final layout, the tree removal plan and the elevations, and applicants should make sure their consultants talk to each other.
Apply the standing advice from the first sketch. A 15 metre buffer from ancient woodland, kept free of buildings and gardens, needs to be drawn on the constraints plan before the layout is designed. Larger buffers may be needed where the likely impacts extend further.
Plan around the survey calendar. Bat activity surveys can only be done in the active season, broadly late spring to early autumn. An appraisal commissioned in winter may mean waiting months for the follow-up. Appealing without it is unlikely to succeed.
Do not rely on conditions. Inspectors continue to apply the long-standing principle that protected species surveys come first.
A checklist for small-site developers
- Commission the ecological appraisal before the layout is fixed.
- Ask the ecologist to list every further survey recommended, with its seasonal window.
- Map ancient woodland, veteran trees and their buffers at the outset.
- Give the ecologist the tree survey, the lighting proposals and the final elevations.
- Keep Biodiversity Net Gain and protected species as separate workstreams. Solving one does not solve the other.
- If the council's ecologist asks for more information, provide it before determination and not at appeal.
Conclusion
The Chaldon decision is a reminder that ecology can decide an appeal even when Green Belt, housing need and Biodiversity Net Gain all point the other way. The site had a woodland on its boundary and a building to be removed. Both were known from the start. What was missing was the survey evidence and a layout that respected the buffer.
Anyone promoting a site next to woodland, or one with buildings or trees to be removed, should arrange a full ecological scoping at the earliest stage, programme the bat surveys for the right season, and make sure the layout is drawn around the findings.
References
- Planning Inspectorate, appeal decision 6010654, 75 and land rear of 77 Rook Lane, Chaldon, decision dated 12 November 2026. appeal-planning-decision.service.gov.uk.
- Natural England and Forestry Commission, Ancient woodland, ancient trees and veteran trees: advice for making planning decisions, GOV.UK. gov.uk.
