West Ashton Appeal 6013972 Dismissed on 18 November 2026: Nine Self-Build Homes Refused for Want of Site-Specific Bat Surveys Near the Bradford on Avon Bats SAC, What It Means for Ecology Surveys (November 2026)

An outline scheme for nine self-build homes on the edge of a Wiltshire village has been refused on appeal, even though the council could show only 2.8 years of housing land supply. Planning Inspectorate appeal 6013972, concerning land east of Yarnbrook Road, West Ashton, was dismissed on 18 November 2026. According to a detailed report of the decision published by Planning Geek on 19 November 2026, the deciding issue was ecological evidence. The appellant's own ecological appraisal said further bat surveys were needed, and those surveys had not been done.

This article summarises what has been reported about the decision and draws out the lessons for landowners, self-builders and small developers commissioning ecology surveys. The appeal reference, site, outcome and decision date are taken from the Planning Inspectorate's appeal record. The account of the inspector's reasoning is taken from the published report.

The site and the proposal

The appeal site is two sloping fields beside Yarnbrook Road, next to the built edge of West Ashton and close to the A350 south of Trowbridge. The application to Wiltshire Council, reference PL/2026/00531, sought outline permission for nine self-build dwellings. Access and layout were submitted for approval. Scale, appearance and landscaping were reserved for later.

The location matters. The land is reported to lie within bat sensitivity zones associated with the Bradford on Avon Bats Special Area of Conservation, and within the zone of influence of the Salisbury Plain Special Protection Area. Development in those zones has to be assessed under the Conservation of Habitats and Species Regulations 2017.

The ecological evidence that was submitted

The appellant is reported to have provided:

  • an updated preliminary ecological appraisal;
  • an indicative ecological parameters plan showing buffers and habitat areas;
  • a signed unilateral undertaking to pay habitat and recreational mitigation contributions;
  • older bat survey data from nearby development sites, including a larger scheme.

The appellant also proposed a planning condition requiring a bat survey to be carried out before the reserved matters stage.

Why the appeal failed

The appraisal itself called for more surveys

The updated preliminary ecological appraisal rated the likelihood of bats using the site for commuting and foraging as moderate and said further surveys were needed. That recommendation had not been followed before the appeal was decided. An inspector faced with an ecologist's own advice that more work is required has little room to conclude that the evidence is sufficient.

Survey data from other sites did not answer the question

The inspector accepted that the older surveys from neighbouring land helped to explain the wider context. They did not establish which bat species used the appeal site, in what numbers, or along which routes. The assessment needed evidence about this land.

Bat surveys could not be left to a condition

The suggested condition was rejected. The inspector noted that the council's bat guidance says surveys for European protected species cannot normally be secured by condition. There was a further difficulty. Layout was one of the matters for approval now. A layout fixed before anyone knows where bats commute and forage cannot be said to respond to them.

Without up-to-date surveys of the site, the illustrative buffers and the ecological parameters plan were treated as assumptions, not as mitigation designed around recorded bat activity.

The appropriate assessment could not be passed

The inspector carried out an appropriate assessment under the Habitats Regulations and could not rule out an adverse effect on the integrity of the Special Area of Conservation with the high level of certainty the law requires. No case was made that the scheme should proceed under the derogation tests. The report describes this as a fundamental legal obstacle, not a matter of detail.

The mitigation payments did not fill the gap

The unilateral undertaking offered contributions towards strategic mitigation. The report records that there was no sound evidence that these formed part of an Environmental Delivery Plan, and that paying towards one form of mitigation cannot answer an unresolved question about a different effect. Contributions towards recreational pressure do not show that a layout avoids severing a commuting route.

The planning balance

The inspector gave substantial weight to nine self-build homes in an area with a serious housing shortfall. Landscape harm was limited, because the fields are contained by the village and existing landscape features. Evidence of highway safety harm was insufficient.

Other concerns were reported: moderate harm in relation to sustainable transport, because the footway along the A350 is unattractive for walking and cycling, and the absence of an archaeological desk-based assessment, which the inspector did not accept could be replaced by a condition.

The ecological issue outweighed the benefits. Where a proposal fails the habitats site test, the weight normally given to housing in an area of shortfall does not rescue it.

Lessons for landowners and small developers

A preliminary ecological appraisal is a starting point

A preliminary appraisal identifies what might be present and what further survey is needed. If it recommends bat activity surveys, the application is not ready until they have been done and reported. Submitting the appraisal alone tells the decision maker that the evidence is incomplete.

Plan around the survey season

Bat activity surveys are seasonal. They are generally carried out during the months when bats are active, with repeat visits spread through that period. A recommendation received in autumn can mean waiting until the following spring and summer. Commissioning the preliminary appraisal early in the year leaves time to complete the follow-up work in the same season.

Fix the layout after the surveys

If layout is to be approved, the ecological evidence has to be capable of supporting that layout. Survey results should inform where plots, roads, lighting and dark corridors go. Where surveys are outstanding, reserving layout does not remove the need for them, but it avoids committing to a design that the evidence may contradict.

Near a protected site, the standard is certainty

Within the influence of a Special Area of Conservation, the question is whether an adverse effect on the integrity of the site can be excluded beyond reasonable scientific doubt. The burden rests on the applicant's evidence. Local mitigation strategies, such as the Trowbridge and Westbury bat mitigation strategy referred to in this appeal, set out what surveys and on-site measures are expected, and should be read before the ecologist is briefed.

Neighbouring data supports a case but cannot make it

Records and surveys from adjoining sites are valuable context. They are not a substitute for knowing how bats use the application site.

Self-build status does not reduce the survey burden

Small and self-build schemes sometimes benefit from lighter requirements elsewhere in the planning system. Protected species law and the Habitats Regulations apply in full whatever the size of the scheme.

Expert ecological evidence at appeal

Planning appeals turn on the quality of the technical evidence. An inspector will read the ecologist's report closely, including its limitations section and its recommendations. An appraisal that candidly says more survey is needed is doing its job. Relying on it while ignoring that recommendation is the problem.

For an appeal, ecological evidence should set out the survey methods and dates, weather conditions, equipment, results by species and location, an assessment of how the site is used, and mitigation that follows from those results. Where a habitats site is involved, it should provide the information the decision maker needs for the appropriate assessment.

How Biodiversity Surveyors can help

We carry out preliminary ecological appraisals, bat roost assessments and bat activity surveys, and prepare the ecological impact assessments, mitigation designs and information for habitats regulations assessment that planning authorities and inspectors expect. If your site is close to a protected area or a known bat population, talk to us before you fix the layout.

Frequently asked questions

What was decided in appeal 6013972?

The Planning Inspectorate dismissed the appeal on 18 November 2026. It concerned an outline application for nine self-build homes on land east of Yarnbrook Road, West Ashton, Wiltshire.

Why was the appeal dismissed?

As reported, the inspector could not rule out an adverse effect on the integrity of the Bradford on Avon Bats Special Area of Conservation, because there were no up-to-date bat surveys of the site itself.

Can bat surveys be required by a planning condition after permission is granted?

Not normally. The presence of protected species and the extent to which they may be affected should be established before permission is granted, so that the decision is made with the full facts.

Is a preliminary ecological appraisal enough for a planning application?

Only if it concludes that no further survey is needed. If it recommends further surveys, those should be completed before the application or appeal is decided.

This article is a general summary for information only and is not legal or planning advice. Details of the inspector's reasoning are taken from published reporting of the decision.

Content Overview
Table of Contents
Search
Categories ----
Recent Post ----